Whilst going through the back issues, finally found the column where Glenn McDonald explains the War Against Silence. Say what you will about the man (and I'm obviously a fan), but it's hard to argue with this: "At its most mundane, music criticism should be a service industry, an attempt to help the reader guess whether there's enough chance that they'd like the album that they ought to buy it and find out." Whatever else I may not agree with McDonald on, most music criticism would be much better if it followed that dictum.
« Home | As much as some of my friends might think otherwis... »
Saturday, July 26, 2003
Post a Comment
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial Share Alike 2.5 Canada License.
About me
Ian Mathers is a freelance writer whose work has appeared in Stylus, the Village Voice, Resident Advisor, PopMatters, and elsewhere. He does stuff and it magically appears here.
Contact Me:
imathers at gmail dot com
Previous posts
- As much as some of my friends might think otherwis...
- Hendy on Christian music. Incredibly entertaining...
- The first movie review at the AV club this week co...
- No really, he's serious this time.
- It's true that Zach Parsons spends far too much ti...
- Just switched over to Firebird from IE, and boy, a...
- Pointed out to me by Tony: Why Ann Coulter upsets...
- This is just far too good. This site doesn't real...
- There is a sidelong reference to why we may never ...
- Kind of startled to run into this right after the ...
Links
- My Blogroll
- Me@Stylus
- Me@RA
- Me@PM
- Me@Flickr
- Me Writing About Low
- 100 Things About Me
- This blog on LJ
- My Record Collection
- Achewood
- Doctor McNinja
- Doonesbury
- 8-Bit Theater
- Joe Loves Crappy Movies
- Married To The Sea
- PartiallyClips
- Questionable Content
- Qwantz
- Scary Go Round
- Shortpacked!
- Allmusic, who art in Heaven
- BBC News
- CBC News
- Drunks On Wheels
- The Onion
- Stylus Magazine
- Suppressive Person Defense League
- Vorgo
- Syndicate this site (XML)
Comics
Good (Non-Syndicated) Sites
Archives
02.03,
03.03,
04.03,
05.03,
06.03,
07.03,
08.03,
09.03,
10.03,
11.03,
12.03,
01.04,
02.04,
03.04,
04.04,
05.04,
06.04,
07.04,
08.04,
09.04,
10.04,
11.04,
12.04,
01.05,
02.05,
03.05,
04.05,
05.05,
06.05,
07.05,
08.05,
09.05,
10.05,
11.05,
12.05,
01.06,
02.06,
03.06,
04.06,
05.06,
06.06,
07.06,
08.06,
09.06,
10.06,
11.06,
12.06,
01.07,
02.07,
03.07,
04.07,
05.07,
06.07,
07.07,
08.07,
09.07,
10.07,
11.07,
12.07,
01.08,
02.08,
03.08,
04.08,
05.08,
06.08,
07.08,
08.08,
09.08,
10.08,
11.08,
12.08,
01.09,
02.09,
03.09,
04.09,
05.09,
06.09,
07.09,
08.09,
09.09,
10.09,
11.09,
12.09,
01.10,
02.10,
03.10,
04.10,
05.10,
06.10,
07.10,
08.10,
09.10,
10.10,
11.10,
12.10,
01.11,
02.11,
03.11,
04.11,
05.11,
06.11,
07.11,