There's a thin line for critics between expertise and snobbery; This gets it half-right and half-wrong. Yes, it is not elitist to have an opinion, and calling people with more specialized knowledge than most (i.e. all good critics, and a good point that Miller makes is that if you are an informed fan you can easily be a critic) 'elitist' is silly. On the other hand, her dismissal of the avant-garde in favour of the old smacks of the reactionary - regardless of whether she, myself, or others like a given piece, if the rest of the crowd does, it's silly to expect them not to applaud. The same goes, incidentially, for rap.
« Home | Vaclav Havel as new George Orwell? Whether you ag... »
Wednesday, April 23, 2003
Post a Comment
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial Share Alike 2.5 Canada License.
About me
Ian Mathers is a freelance writer whose work has appeared in Stylus, the Village Voice, Resident Advisor, PopMatters, and elsewhere. He does stuff and it magically appears here.
Contact Me:
imathers at gmail dot com
Previous posts
- Vaclav Havel as new George Orwell? Whether you ag...
- Another example of the Onion sneaking valuable inf...
- Sigh. It'd be nice if things didn't work this way...
- For fuck's sake, you can't punish a sovreign natio...
- I really, really hate to kind of agree with Limbau...
- Parish's art and updates have been really top-notc...
- Women are special.
- Today is three distinct things; Earth Day, my dog'...
- This is why I love Achewood. Also, this. I've be...
- Sweden is weird.
Links
- My Blogroll
- Me@Stylus
- Me@RA
- Me@PM
- Me@Flickr
- Me Writing About Low
- 100 Things About Me
- This blog on LJ
- My Record Collection
- Achewood
- Doctor McNinja
- Doonesbury
- 8-Bit Theater
- Joe Loves Crappy Movies
- Married To The Sea
- PartiallyClips
- Questionable Content
- Qwantz
- Scary Go Round
- Shortpacked!
- Allmusic, who art in Heaven
- BBC News
- CBC News
- Drunks On Wheels
- The Onion
- Stylus Magazine
- Suppressive Person Defense League
- Vorgo
- Syndicate this site (XML)
Comics
Good (Non-Syndicated) Sites
Archives
02.03,
03.03,
04.03,
05.03,
06.03,
07.03,
08.03,
09.03,
10.03,
11.03,
12.03,
01.04,
02.04,
03.04,
04.04,
05.04,
06.04,
07.04,
08.04,
09.04,
10.04,
11.04,
12.04,
01.05,
02.05,
03.05,
04.05,
05.05,
06.05,
07.05,
08.05,
09.05,
10.05,
11.05,
12.05,
01.06,
02.06,
03.06,
04.06,
05.06,
06.06,
07.06,
08.06,
09.06,
10.06,
11.06,
12.06,
01.07,
02.07,
03.07,
04.07,
05.07,
06.07,
07.07,
08.07,
09.07,
10.07,
11.07,
12.07,
01.08,
02.08,
03.08,
04.08,
05.08,
06.08,
07.08,
08.08,
09.08,
10.08,
11.08,
12.08,
01.09,
02.09,
03.09,
04.09,
05.09,
06.09,
07.09,
08.09,
09.09,
10.09,
11.09,
12.09,
01.10,
02.10,
03.10,
04.10,
05.10,
06.10,
07.10,
08.10,
09.10,
10.10,
11.10,
12.10,
01.11,
02.11,
03.11,
04.11,
05.11,
06.11,
07.11,